In a judgment delivered on 11 November 2026, the High Court granted leave to enforce an adjudicator's decision under the Construction Contracts Act 2013 (the "2013 Act"). It refused a stay sought despite a deeply distressing incident under active Garda investigation. Judge Twomey opened by describing it as "a very unusual case". The decision shows how firmly the Irish courts will protect the statutory right to prompt payment, even where very difficult ancillary issues arise.
Background
On 27 July 2026, an adjudicator found that the respondent owed the applicant €314,868.88 plus VAT for completed building works. The applicant's original claim was €563,326.09.
Two days later, two unidentified men called at the home of one of the respondent's directors and effectively demanded payment of €563,000. On the date of this article, that incident remains under investigation.
The respondent did not dispute that the works had been done, that the sum was owed, or that the adjudicator's decision bound it. It asked the Court to use its discretion under s. 6(11) of the 2013 Act to stay enforcement until the criminal process had concluded. It argued that allowing the applicant to profit from civil execution while the Gardaí investigated the incident would be contrary to public policy and to the rule of law.
The Decision
The Court refused the stay; its reasoning was:
- A stay would significantly restrict a builder's right to be paid for work actually done and would turn the "pay now, argue later" system into "argue now, pay later".
- The applicant would be significantly prejudiced by a delay that could last months or years. The respondent would suffer no relevant prejudice by paying a sum it accepted was due.
- The Court had no basis for attributing the men's actions to the applicant or its director. A stay would require the civil courts to assume guilt.
- Even if wrongdoing was established, the debt would remain due and no right of set-off would arise.
- The Court agreed that using extra-judicial methods to enforce a debt would be "an affront to the rule of law". It held, however, that the proper response lies with the Gardaí and the criminal justice system. "The rule of law involves guilt being proven, not assumed".
The Court described what happened to the respondent's director as "hugely concerning". It anticipated a full investigation and, if justified, "the full force of the law" being brought against any wrongdoers.
Commentary
The case shows how narrow the grounds for resisting enforcement of an adjudicator's decision are.
Paying parties should therefore assume that an adjudicator's decision will be enforced promptly. Any separate grievance, however serious, will generally have to be pursued through its own process.
Our Construction team regularly advises employers, contractors and subcontractors on adjudication, payment disputes and enforcement proceedings. For more information, please contact Fiona Egan or Barry Cahir.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice.