In 2025, we examined the High Court's decision in Albert Connaughton v Timber Frame Projects Ltd [2025] IEHC 469, in which the Court drew a clear boundary around the scope of statutory adjudication under the Construction Contracts Act 2013 (the CCA). Simons J. held that the right to refer a dispute to statutory adjudication under the CCA is confined to payments provided for under the contract. That right does not extend to claims for common law damages following a repudiatory termination.
That position has now been endorsed by the Court of Appeal. In a judgment delivered on 13 November 2026 ([2026] IECA 216), the Court dismissed the employer's appeal, confirming that claims for repudiatory termination fall outside the statutory adjudication regime. What had been a High Court ruling is now binding appellate authority.
The Appeal
By way of reminder, the employer had paid €124,891 to the respondent towards a prefabricated timber-frame house that was never erected. He treated the contract as terminated for repudiatory breach and referred the dispute for adjudication under section 6(1) of the CCA. An adjudicator awarded him €184,119.87, being a full refund of the sums paid plus consequential losses.
On appeal, the employer argued that the words "any dispute relating to payment arising under the construction contract" in Section 6(1) are general words and should be read widely. In the alternative, he argued that the €124,891 refund element, at least, could be enforced as a payment dispute because it was simply the return of money paid under the contract.
The Decision
The Court rejected both arguments.
Three points stand out.
- Substance over arithmetic. The claim was, in law, one for unliquidated damages for breach of contract. The fact that elements of the claim "mirrored the amounts" paid under the contract "did not alter the legal nature of the claim." Recasting the refund as a restitutionary claim for money had and received made no difference. Like damages, that is a remedy the general law provides against a party who fails to perform, and it depends on a finding that the contract is at an end.
- A clear test. The Court held that the ambit of Section 6(1) is "confined to disputes as to whether one party to a construction contract is entitled to receive a payment from the other party in satisfaction of an obligation which arises from the express or implied terms of that contract." Put simply, the question is whether the amount claimed is owed. Payment disputes include interim and final payments, liquidated damages for delay, refunds of overpayments where the contract provides for them, and unexplained failures to pay. These are claims "based on contractual indebtedness."
- Statutory context. The Court gave several reasons for this reading. The long title of the CCA refers to regulating "payments under construction contracts". The 28-day timetable is unrealistic for deciding repudiation and assessing loss. Adjudicating part of a "unitary" damages claim while leaving the rest to the courts would be anomalous. Clear wording is also needed before a statute can restrict access to the courts or arbitration. The Court also contrasted Section 108 of the UK Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996, which permits referral of any dispute "arising under the contract".
The Section 4 Question: Answered
Our earlier article left one question open: is compliance with the payment claim notice procedure in Section 4 a prerequisite to referral under Section 6? The High Court had acknowledged a link between the two sections but declined to decide the point.
The Court of Appeal has now answered this question. Owens J. rejected any connection between Sections 4 and 6 "beyond that the purpose of both of those provisions is to assist in enforcement of payment obligations." Where a contractor is out of time to serve a payment claim notice, or does not use the Section 4 procedure at all, "either of the parties to the construction contract may invoke the right to refer to adjudication." The Court also confirmed that Section 6 is not confined to the employer's payment obligations: employers can refer payment disputes too.
Takeaways
- Characterise the claim before referring. Ask whether you are claiming a sum the contract obliges the other party to pay, or compensation for its failure to perform. Only the former can go to statutory adjudication.
- Use contractual termination mechanisms. As we noted previously, standard forms such as Clause 33 of the RIAI form and Clause 15 of the FIDIC Red Book provide for payments on termination. Claims under these provisions remain adjudicable. A common law termination puts the dispute in the courts.
- Draft for advance payments. Where substantial sums are paid upfront, as is common in modular and offsite construction, an express obligation to refund on termination or non-delivery may turn a damages claim into an adjudicable debt.
- Non-participation is not fatal. The respondent did not take part in the adjudication, yet it resisted enforcement successfully. Adjudicators must test their jurisdiction at the outset.
If you would like to discuss the decision and its implications, please contact Fiona Egan, Richard Stowe, Tristan Egly or Philip Hayden in our Construction team.